I was fine, just hanging out
I was living like a player in a west coast town, yeah
I never thought that I would ever settle down
It was one girl after the other
Didn't wanna be her boyfriend
All I needed was her number, yeah
Let me share a little bit of what I found

There were so many flavors I wanted to taste
Then Jayme, thought she was the one till she
Played me just like twenty one then
Katie, I couldn't get enough
She was just like Pumpkin Pie.
But then Katie, she kinda had a thing with Stacey
And that was pretty fun but
Lately I wanna go to sleep with the same girl
The same girl every night

Ah ah ah ah

Some girls should come with a warning
And a dose of pinacillin first thing in the morning
But last night it never really crossed my mind
Always one girl after the other
I was hitting on your roommate
I was flirting with your mother
And now I get the feeling it was always that time

Jayme, thought she was the one till she
Played me just like twenty one then
Katie, I couldn't get enough
She was just like Pumpkin Pie.
But then Katie, she kinda had a thing with Stacey
And that was pretty fun but
Lately I wanna go to sleep with the same girl
The same girl every night

Same girl every night
Who wants the same guy every night
And the same bed every night
Every single night
I want the same girl every night
Who wants the same guy every night
A perfect simple life
Every single night

Jayme, thought she was the one till she
Played me just like twenty one then
Katie, I couldn't get enough
She was just like Pumpkin Pie
And maybe you're the only one who that can save me
And maybe I'm in luck, cause lately
I want to go to sleep with the same girl
Same girl every night